FISH of SanCap Friendly Faces Welcomes Sanibel Native Michael Billheimer for a Look Back at Island Life

FISH of SanCap will welcome longtime island resident and former Lighthouse Café owner Michael Billheimer as the guest speaker for its December Friendly Faces luncheon. Billheimer will share stories about growing up on Sanibel, his family’s long history on the island and his 32 years running one of Sanibel’s most popular restaurants.

The gathering will take place Tuesday, Dec. 8, beginning at 11:00 a.m. at Sanibel Community Church, 1740 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel. Lunch is provided, and reservations are requested by Dec. 4 at https://friendlyfacesdec2026.rsvpify.com.

A third-generation island resident, Billheimer has family roots on Sanibel dating back to 1898. His family purchased beachfront property from the Bailey family and established High Tide Cottages, now known as High Tide Condominium. He grew up on the island, attended Sanibel Elementary School and learned the hospitality business through his family’s vacation rental operation.

After earning a degree in Hospitality and Restaurant Management from Florida International University and working with Marriott Corporation, Billheimer returned home to take over the Lighthouse Café, purchasing the restaurant in 1988. For 32 years, he was a familiar face to generations of island residents and visitors before passing ownership to his nephew, Dan Billheimer, in 2018.

Billheimer has also served as president of the Sanibel & Captiva Islands Chamber of Commerce and on the Sanibel Planning Commission. Today, he works in real estate, sharing his knowledge of the islands with those looking to make Sanibel or Captiva their home.

His connection to FISH is personal. His mother, Barbara Billheimer, was among the organization’s earliest volunteers, working with FISH co-founder Abe Lerner when the organization was a small group of neighbors checking on older residents and providing rides to medical appointments, pharmacies and other errands. Barbara continued her commitment to FISH and the Sanibel Public Library throughout her 34 years of retirement until her passing in 2011 at age 93.

“Michael is part of Sanibel’s history, and we are so pleased to have him join us,” said Erika Arnowitz, FISH Senior Services Director. “Between his family’s history, his years at the Lighthouse Café and his mother’s connection to the early days of FISH, he has so many stories to share. I think our guests will especially enjoy hearing what island life was like years ago and how much has changed.”

Friendly Faces is offered through FISH Senior Services and is open to everyone, regardless of age. The monthly gathering brings neighbors together for lunch, conversation and guest speakers who share information, experiences and stories connected to the community.

The December luncheon begins at 11:00 a.m. on Tuesday, Dec. 8 at Sanibel Community Church, 1740 Periwinkle Way. Lunch is provided, and reservations are requested at https://friendlyfacesdec2026.rsvpify.com.

Individuals interested in learning more about FISH programs or exploring available resources may contact FISH at 239-472-4775 or visit www.fishofsancap.org.

Translate »